COMPENDIUM OF WORLD HISTORY
VOLUME 1
A Dissertation Presented to The Faculty of the Ambassador College Graduate
School of Theology In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree
Doctor of Theology
by Herman L. Hoeh
1962(1963-1965, 1967 Edition)
CHAPTER ELEVEN
Berossus and Babylonian History
The writings of Berossus, the contemporary of Manetho, are altogether lost.
No valid dates of individual kings have been preserved by classic writers from
Berossus.
Berossus’ first post-flood dynasty is completely distorted. It is said to
be composed of 86 Chaldean kings who supposedly reigned about 34,000 years!
This dynasty includes Evechous and Kosmabelos — Cush and Nimrod. The kings
who composed the first dynasty were not successive but contemporary leaders
who formed the first Democratic Council in history this side of the flood. Samuel
Kramer, in his book ‘History Begins at Sumer’, draws attention to the fact that
the earliest records of democratic government are found in references to Shinar
and the city of Kish.
The other dynasties of Berossus strikingly confirm the Sumerian King List
and Biblical history. The following chart is from Berossus’ transcribers.
|
Dynasty II |
8 Medes |
224 years (the Armenian copy reads 234) |
|
Dynasty III |
11 Chaldeans |
NO YEARS ASSIGNED, AS DYNASTY WAS CONTEMPORARY. (In margin of Armenian |
|
Dynasty IV |
49 Chaldeans |
458 years |
|
Dynasty V |
9 Arabians |
245 years (Semiramis II reigned during this period.) |
|
Dynasty VI |
45 Chaldeans |
526 years to seizure of Babylonia by Pul. |
The dates for these dynasties may easily be restored. Pul, in Babylonian
history, is Tiglathpileser III. He seized the city of Babylon in 729, during
the third year of the reign of Ukinzer. See the ‘Babylonian Chronicle’, Col
I. Tiglathpileser considered this his first year; the Babylonians considered
it his accession year assigning it to Ukinzer. Ptolemy coupled them together
and designated the period as that of Chinziros and Poros.
|
Dynasty VI |
continued 526 years |
— |
1255 to 729 |
|
Dynasty V |
for 245 years |
— |
1500 to 1255 |
|
Dynasty IV |
for 458 years |
— |
1958 to 1500 |
|
(Dynasty III |
for 48 years |
— |
2006-1958) |
|
Dynasty II |
for 234 years |
— |
2192-1958 |
|
or |
|||
|
224 years |
— |
2192-1968 |
The year 2192 marks not only the beginning of Nimrod’s rule in Egypt, but
also the Median seizure of Babylonia at the time Nimrod usurped Supreme authority
at the dethroning of his father cush. This confirms Greek traditions that even
Japetus (Japheth) opposed the Titans — the followers of Nimrod. The Medes,
descendents of Japheth kept their power over Babylon for 224 years to 1968 —
the year of the death of Gilgamesh. In another ten years (1968-1958) the Chaldeans
regained full power.
Those ten years and the previous 38 were times of great stress during which
11 Chaldean kings, including Gilgamesh, ruled contemporaneously as Berossus’
Dynasty III — 2006-1958. The date 2006 is confirmed by the Persian account
of Gilgamesh. Persian historians assign him only 38 years — 2006-1968 — the
exact duration of his rule as part of Dynasty III of Berossus. (See Al Biruni’s
‘Ancient Nations’, page 99.) The remarkable agreement of all these figures,
found among different nations, is proof that the historical data have never
been totally lost.
Another Account of Earliest Dynasties
As generally recorded, Berossus’ First Dynasty begins with Cush and Nimrod;
the Second Dynasty was Median. But Alexander Polyhistor and Abydenus preserve,
from the most ancient records of the Temple of Belus at Babylon, an account
of parallel rulers — five Chaldean kings who were in turn succeeded by no less
than six Arabians (pre-Ishmaelites). The information may be obtained from Jackson’s
‘Chronological Antiquities’, Pages 233-235. These much-misunderstood dynasties
— even Jackson did not understand their import — perfectly correspond with
the restoration of the Dynasty of Erech already presented.
| First Kings of the Chaldeans after the Tower of Babel |
Lengths of Reign |
Dates |
|
Porus |
35 |
2254-2219 |
|
Nechubes |
43 |
2219-2176 |
|
Abtus |
48 |
2176-2128 |
|
Oniballus |
40 |
2128-2088 |
|
Zinzirus |
45 (or 46) |
2088-2043 (2088-2042) |
(Note that the 35 years — 2254-2219 — of Porus are also the same for Mizraim.)
|
Dynasty of Six Kings of the Arabians |
Lengths of Reign |
Dates |
|
Mardocentes |
45 (or 44) |
(2042-1998) |
|
Mardakos |
40 |
1998-1958 |
(the year 1958 marks the final expulsion of the Medes from Babylonia.)
|
Sisimardacus |
28 |
1958-1930 |
|
Nabius |
37 |
1930-1893 |
|
Parannus |
40 |
1893-1853 |
|
Nabonnabus |
25 |
1853-1828 |
In 1828, ‘the Assyrian kings succeeded in the Babylonian Empire, and thenceforth
Babylonia and Chaldea became a part of the Assyrian Empire’ — Page 237, Jackson’s
‘Chronological Antiquities’. This is also the year of the defeat of Erech by
Ur. Syncellus preserved a total of 190 years for the Chaldean kings, and not
the above total of 211 — though his separate figures add up to 211! It is exactly
190 years from 2233 to 2043. The year 2233 was famous in Babylonian history
as the beginning of astronomical observation. The Babylonians began their observations
1903 years before Alexander came to Babylon in 330.
First Dynasty of Ur and Successors
The city of Ur in Babylonian history is not the Ur from which Abram came.
Abram’s Ur was Urfa in northern Mesopotamia, not on the fringes of Shinar.
According to the Sumerian King List, the First Dynasty of Ur came to power
at the close of the First Dynasty of Erech.
|
Names of Kings of First Dynasty of Ur |
Lengths of Reign |
Dates |
|
Mes-Anne-padda |
80 (includes reign of son A-Anne-padda) |
1828-1748 |
|
Mes-kiag-Nunna |
30 |
1748-1718 |
|
(or 36) |
1748-1712 |
|
|
Elulu |
25 |
1718-1693 |
|
Balulu |
36 |
1693-1657 |
The significance of the 36 years of Mes-kiag-Nunna will be explained when
the Dynasty of Akshak is restored. The proper dates of Dynasty I of Ur are those
of the Nippur list, which gives the total as 171 — 1828-1657. (The Weld-Blundell
Prism 444 adds the parallel reign of six years of Mes-kiag-Nunna to the total.)
At the close of the First Dynasty of Ur the Sumerian King List carries the
government to the city of Awan in Elam (see page 224 of Pallis’ ‘Chronology
of the Shub-Ad Culture’). Reference to three kings is made, but only a cuneiform
remnant of the last king’s name is preserved: Kul … 36 years. The total length
of the Dynasty is 356 years — 1657-1301. The date of the last king is therefore
1337-1301. A confirmation of these dates will be found in the succeeding history
of the city of Isin and Dynasty III of Ur.
Historically the date 1657 marks Elamite prominence in Southern Mesopotamia
and throws important light on the early history of India.
After Awan the Sumerian King List returns to Dynasty II of Kish. Though the
names of the rulers of Kish during this period are preserved, the dates assigned
to its rulers are extravagant — over 3000 years being designated to 8 kings.
Kish II begins about the time of the reigns of Gilgamesh and Mes-anne-padda,
whose lives overlapped; for the last king of Kish I submitted to both (see the
Sumerian poem ‘Gilgamesh and Aqqa’ in Pritchard’s Texts). The true length of
Dynasty II is confirmed by Kish III and IV which we will now establish.
Listed after Kish II, though in part contemporary with it, is the Dynasty
of Hamazi. Only one name of this dynasty is preserved: Hadanish. The total length
of the dynasty is sometimes given as 360 years, sometimes as 420. It cannot
be dated until Dynasty II and Dynasty III of Uruk are determined.
The shattered list of Dynasty II of Uruk is in the prism given 60 years and
120 years. In other documents it ends a period of 480 years. There is a definite
relationship between these figures and those of Hamazi. But Uruk II and Hamazi
cannot be dated until Uruk III is established.
From archaeology it is known that Uruk II was followed immediately by Uruk
III — though the King List branches off into parallel dynasties. Uruk III is
composed of one King Lugal-zaggisi, who reigned 25 years. Comparative archaeology
establishes that he succeeded Ur I, 1828-1657. The date of king Lugal-zaggisi
is therefore 1657-1632.
As Uruk II preceded Uruk III, the 480 years extend back from 1657 to 2137.
That is, the year 1657 ended an era of 480 years which began in 2137. As Uruk
I ended in 1828, Uruk II lasted only 171 years 1828-1657. The figure 480 is
not the length of the dynasty but the dating of an era. What happened in the
year 2137? Isis (Ishtar or Semiramis) came to power after the 57-year era (2194-2137)
of Nimrod. It was commonplace to date reigns in the ‘Era of Ishtar’ (see Pritchard’s
‘Texts’, page 266, in Sargon’s ‘Chronicle’, and footnote 2). In chart form the
figures for Uruk II are as follows.
|
480 years |
— |
2137-1657 |
|
120 years |
— |
1777-1657 |
|
60 years |
— |
1717-1657 |
Now the Dynasty of Hamazi may be dated:
|
360 years |
— |
2137-1777 |
|
420 years |
— |
2137-1717 |
Both these dynasties commenced with the Era of Ishtar. In another chart these
two would appear as follows:
|
Hamazi |
360 years |
2137-1777 |
|
Uruk II |
120 years |
1777-1657 |
or
|
Hamazi |
420 years |
2137-1717 |
|
Uruk II |
60 years |
1717-1657 |
Skipping for the moment other parallel Dynasties, notice that Uruk III was
succeeded by the Dynasty of Akkad. Uruk III — composed of one king Lugal-zaggisi
— extended for 25 years to 1632.
Now Sargon of Akkad
The greatest name in Babylonian history in this period is undoubtedly that
of Sargon ‘the Great’ — first king of the Acadian Dynasty. The history of this
dynasty has been confused by the Weld-Blundell Prism 444. The complete and correct
record is that of the Nippur lists. Prism 444 is incomplete.
| Names of Kings of Dynasty of Akkad |
Lengths of Reign |
Dates |
|
Sargon |
55 |
1632-1577 |
|
Rimush |
15 |
1577-1562 |
|
Manish-tusu |
7 |
1562-1555 |
|
Naram-Sin |
56 |
1555-1499 |
|
Sharkalisharri |
24 or |
1499-1475 |
|
25 |
1500-1475 |
|
|
Igigi, Nanum, Imi |
3 years of confusion |
1475-1472 |
|
Dudu |
21 |
1472-1451 |
|
Shudurul |
15 |
1451-1436 |
The reign of Sharkalisharri confirms Berossus, who dates the Arabian invasion
in 1500. It toppled Naram-Sin from his power and brought his successor to a
weakened throne. Naram-Sin died after one more year of reign. Rimush is the
younger twin brother of Manish-tusu (Jacobsen, ‘Sumerian King List’, p. 113).
He overthrew an otherwise unknown Kaku of Ur.
The Weld-Blundell Prism 444 is fractured in the middle of the history of
this dynasty. However, its total indicates that Naram-Sin’s reign is cut short
and does not include part of the period of his subjection to the invading Guti
hordes. It also gives different figures for the three early rulers as follows.
|
Sargon |
56 years |
1633-1577 |
|
Rimush |
9 |
1577-1568 |
|
Manish-tusu |
15 |
1568-1553 |
Year 1633 is the accession year of Sargon.
This document(W.-B. 444) by itself is not a proper standard for Babylonian
history. It should be used in conjunction with the other lists rather than by
itself as is customarily done by modern authors.
Dynasties IV and V of Erech
The collapse of the Dynasty of Akkad brought Erech again into prominence.
In the Scheil Text the Fourth Dynasty of Uruk is listed as follows:
| Names of Kings of Dynasty IV of Uruk |
Lengths of Reign in Scheil Text |
Dates |
|
Ur-Niginak |
3 |
1436-1433 |
|
Ur-Gigirak |
6 |
1433-1427 |
|
Kudda |
6 |
1427-1421 |
|
Puzur-ili |
5 |
1421-1416 |
|
Ur-Utuk |
6 |
1416-1410 |
The Weld-Blundell prism assigns 7 years to the first king — 1440-1433.
Fragment C of the Susa list of these kings follows (see ‘Journal of Near
Eastern Studies’, Apr. 1960, p. 157).
| Name of Kings of Dynasty IV of Uruk |
Lengths of Reign |
Dates |
|
Ur-Gigirak |
15 |
1442-1427 |
|
Lugal-me-lam |
7 |
1442-1435 |
|
Ur-Utuk |
25 |
1435-1410 |
In this list the contemporary reigns of Kudda and Puzur-ili are incorporated
in the long reign of Ur-Utuk. As in Egyptian history, numerous rulers shared
the government at the same time. In another fragment of the Susa list the following
information is preserved for the first three kings:
|
Ur-Niginak |
30 |
1472-1442 |
|
Ur-Gigirak |
15 |
1442-1427 |
|
Lugal-me-lam |
7 |
1442-1435 |
What is the significance of the year 1472? It is the end of three years of
confusion (1475-1472) under the Acadian Dynasty when four kings ruled. During
that period it became proofrbial to ask: ‘who was king? who was not?’ Far from
being bad scribal errors, these various figures for Dynasty IV of Uruk tell
much of the story that is otherwise unpreserved. The real rise to power commenced
in 1472, though the kings of Uruk did not replace the kings of Akkad until 1436.
The kingship over Uruk was obtained in 1410 by Utuhegal, who constitutes
Dynasty V. All documents agree in giving full 7 years to this short-lived Dynasty
— 1410-1403. Utuhegal gained prominence at the beginning of his reign by overthrowing
the Guti who had invaded Babylonia 125 years before, in 1535, and wrested complete
control in a second attack in 1500 (see the dates from the W.-B. Prism 444).
The Guti Dynasty
Berossus designates 1500 as the year in which an Arabian dynasty of 9 kings
wrested control of Babylonia from the Chaldeans. Coupled with this invasion
from Arabia was one from the east under the Guti. The Guti Dynasty is not complete
in any one document, but may be determined from a comparison of each of the
documents. Its first King is nowhere preserved in the King Lists, but an otherwise
unknown king of the Guti has been found. As he is the only Guti king known to
have usurped the titles of Naram-Sin, it is quite clear that he — Erridupizir
— should head the list as the leader in the initial attack on Akkad in 1535.
(Jacobsen’s , ‘King List’, p. 117, from Hilprecht’s ‘The Earliest Version of
the Babylonian Deluge Story and The Temple Library of Nippur’. Pennsylvania
Univ. Babylonian Expedition, Series D: Researches and Treatises V 1 (1910),
chap. 4.)
The initials in brackets in the following list indicate the source of the
different reading. Their significance will be explained afterward.
| Kings of the Guti |
Lengths of Reign |
Dates |
|
(Erridupizir) |
(33 — restored by subtraction from dynastic totals) |
1535-1502 |
|
Imta |
3 |
1502-1499 |
|
5 (L1) |
1504-1499 |
|
|
Inkishush |
6 or |
1499-1493 |
|
7 (L1) |
1500-1493 |
|
|
Sarlagab |
6 |
1493-1487 |
|
Shulme (or Iarlagash in L1) |
6 |
1487-1481 |
|
Elulumesh |
7 (G) |
1481-1474 |
|
or 6 |
1481-1475 |
|
|
Inimabakesh |
5 |
1474-1469 |
|
Igeshaush |
6 |
1469-1463 |
|
Jarlagab |
15 |
1463-1448 |
|
Ibate |
3 |
1448-1445 |
|
Jarla(ngab) |
3 |
1445-1442 |
|
Kurum |
1 |
1442-1441 |
|
Habilkin |
3 |
1441-1438 |
|
Laerabum |
2 |
1438-1436 |
|
Irraum |
2 |
1436-1434 |
|
Ibranum |
1 |
1434-1433 |
|
Hablum |
2 |
1433-1431 |
|
Puzur-Sin |
7 |
1431-1424 |
|
Jarlaganda |
7 |
1424-1417 |
|
Sium |
7 |
1417-1410 |
|
Tirigan |
40 days |
1410 |
The second king is, in one tablet, assigned 5 years instead of 3. This indicates
that Erridupizir may have reigned the last two years (1504-1502) jointly with
Imta. The different lengths assigned to the reign of the third king — Inkishush
— exactly fits the years 1500 and 1499 which overlap in the account of the
Acadian Dynasty. The variation in the reign of Elulumesh, the sixth king, is
again made plain by the struggle for power recorded in the Acadian Dynasty for
1475-1472. The king’s total reign was 7 years, but only six to the year 1475,
when the struggle for power in Babylonia commenced.
Three Other Dynasties
The coming of the Guti into Babylonia brought further division to the land.
At the city of Ur a new Dynasty rose to power and lasted 108 years according
to the Nippur List. The total for the Dynasty is missing from the document,
but the total for Dynasties I, II and III is plainly given as 396. Dynasty I
ruled 171 years; Dynasty III, 117, as will be noticed shortly. These two figures,
subtracted from 396, leave 108.
The royal names of this dynasty are nearly illegible, and no internal dates
are preserved. The Dynasty may be dismissed with the dates: 1535-1427.
In 1427 the Dynasty of Adab succeeded Ur II according to the Sumerian King
List. It exercised authority in Babylonia for 90 years — until 1337. The only
name of a king of this Dynasty is that of Lugal-Annemundu. The collective verb
— ‘they reigned’ — indicates other names are lost.
At the same time that Ur II lost control to the city of Adab, another city,
far distant, on the Middle Euphrates, came into power. It was the city of Ma
(e) ri. Mari later became famous as a town bordering on Israel’s territory on
the Euphrates. The Mari Dynasty, placed after Adab in the King Lists, was, in
point of fact, contemporary. It lasted 136 years — 1427-1291. All that has
been thus far discovered of its rulers is a tattered document that looks like
the following:
| Fragmentary Names of Mari Kings |
Lengths of Reign |
Dates |
|
Ansud |
30 |
1427-1397 |
Total: six kings for 136 years.
The year 1291 will become significant in the study of Kish IV.
Dynasty III of Ur
Meanwhile the city of Ur revived and another powerful dynasty came to power
— the Third. This dynasty was made famous by Woolley’s excavations at Ur. It
succeeded Dynasty V of Erech, and reigned for 117 years according to the Nippur
List. Its first king once was functionary of Utuhegal before Ur rebelled and
seized political prominence. Utuhegal (Uruk V) ruled 1410-1403.
| Kings of Dynasty III of Ur according to the Nippur List |
Lengths of Reign |
Dates |
|
Ur-Nammu |
18 |
1403-1385 |
|
Shulgi (often spelled: Dungi) |
58 |
1385-1327 |
|
Amar-Sin (often spelled: Bur-Sin) |
9 |
1327-1318 |
|
Shu-Sin |
7 |
1318-1311 |
|
Ibbi-Sin |
25 |
1311-1286 |
Fragment C of the Susa List has a different account of this Dynasty. This
account is usually rejected, merely because it is different from the preceding
one.
But in it is a key to yet a third account of the same dynasty! The duration
of Ur III was 117 years — 1403-1286.
| Kings of Dynasty III of Ur according to Susa List |
Lengths of Reign |
Dates |
|
Ur-Namme |
18 |
1403-1385 |
|
Shulgi |
48 |
1385-1337 |
|
Amar-Sin |
25 |
1339-1314 |
|
Shu-Sin |
16 |
1318-1302 |
|
Ibbi-Sin |
15 |
1302-1287 |
This list does not include the last year of Ibbi-Sin, during which he was
carried captive to Elam. But, as in the Nippur List, it does include that year
in its dynastic total (123 years), which is one year more than the total assigned
to all the kings (122 years).*
The 48-year reign of Shulgi assigned in the Susa List stops in 1337. This
date is significant. It marks the end of the Adab Dynasty (already discussed).
It also is the beginning of the reign of ‘Kul scribe recording the Susa List
does not give the last 10 years of Shulgi as it is incorporated in the long
reign of Amar-Sin.
The Weld-Blundell Prism 444 differs from either preceding list in its length
of the reign of Shulgi, which it gives as 46 — 1385-1339. This dating provides
the clue to the proper beginning of the 25-year reign of Amar-Sin as recorded
in the Susa List. Also, W.-B 444 shortens the reign of Ibbi-Sin to 24 years
— 1311-1287, ending it in the same year as the Susa scribe does. That is, it
does not include the last year in which the king was taken captive. It also
assigns 9 years to Shu-Sin, probably the 9 years from 1311 (when Ibbi-Sin came
to power) to the year 1302 (the last year of Shu-Sin in the Susa List).
(*Note: dynastic total of 123 years includes coregencies.)
Dynasty of Isin
During the reign of Ibbi-Sin of Ur the Elamites made inroads into the land
of Shinar. This is the time that Elamite Awan dominated part of Babylonia under
its last king.
The question of the corresponding years between Ibbi-Sin of Ur III and Ishbi-Irra,
first king of Isin, has led to many learned articles in all the journals on
Near Eastern Studies. The question cannot be determined by itself. Vital information
is missing for the earliest years of Ishbi-Irra. The problem can be resolved,
however, when combining the known facts with the information contained in Dynasty
IV of Kish. Why no historian has ventured to correlate Kish with both dynasties
is a mystery: If they had done so, they would have resolved the difficulties.
The following outline history of the Dynasty of Isin begins with the correlation
of Ibbi-Sin’s year 24 with Ishbi-Irra’s year 14, and year 25 of Ibbi-Sin with
year 15 of Ishbi-Irra. This correlation is one of several possibilities commonly
espoused. It is, however, the only one which harmonizes with the history of
Kish IV — a fact to be proofd in a succeeding section.
| Kings of Isin |
Lengths of Reign |
Dates |
|
Ishbi-Irra |
33 |
1301-1268 |
|
Shu-ilishu |
10 |
1268-1258 |
|
I(d)din-Dagan |
21 |
1258-1237 |
|
Ishme-Dagan |
20 |
1237-1217 |
|
Lipit-Ishtar |
11 |
1217-1206 |
|
Ur-Ninurta |
28 |
1206-1178 |
|
Bur-Sin |
21 |
1178-1157 |
|
Lipit-Enlil |
5 |
1157-1152 |
|
Irra-imitti |
8 |
1152-1144 |
|
Enlil-bani |
24 |
1144-1120 |
|
Zambia |
3 |
1120-1117 |
|
Iter-pisha |
4 |
1117-1113 |
|
Ur-Dukuga |
4 |
1113-1109 |
|
Sin-magir |
11 |
1109-1098 |
|
Damiq-ilishu |
23 |
1098-1075 |
In 1075 Damiq-ilishu was overthrown by Rimsin of Larsa, who was in turn overthrown
by Hammurabi.
The above list is the recognized standard for the Dynasty of Isin. Minor
variations occur in two documents discussed in the ‘Journal of Cuneiform Studies’,
VIII, 4, ‘New Lists of the Kings of Ur and Isin.’ In them the year in which
Ishbi-Irra came to power is treated as the accession year — only 32 are assigned
him. Ishme-Dagan is given 19 instead of 20, but Bur-Sin is assigned 22 instead
of 21. In other documents the last year of Irra-imitti is replaced by a ursurper.
Dynasty IV of Kish and the ‘400 Years’
The records of Dynasty IV of Kish are so divergent — and unusual — that
no historian or archaeologist would accept them. ‘Corrupt,’ ‘worthless,’ are
the common epithets applied. No one has tested the evidence to see if the accounts
are, in fact, true’!
In the Scheil Text (left) and the Weld-Blundell Prism 444 (right) Dynasties
III and IV of Kish appear as follows:
| Names of Rulers | Scheil Text | W.-B 444 |
|
(Dynasty III) Ku-Baba, a queen |
100 years |
— |
|
(Dynasty IV) Puzur-Sin |
25 years |
25 years |
|
Ur-Zababa |
6 years |
400 years |
|
Simudar |
30 years |
30 years |
|
Usiwatar |
6 years |
7 years |
|
Ishtarmuti |
11 years |
11 years |
|
Ishme-Shamash |
11 years |
11 years |
|
Nannia |
3 years |
7 years |
Total 28 kings — 586 years.
The 586 years of the Scheil Text includes the 400 not listed, minus the 6
which is listed: 100 plus 25 plus (400) plus 30 plus 6 plus 11 plus 11 plus
3 equals 586.
Now compare this with the evidence of the Susa Text. Notice the changed order
of kings.
|
Puzur-Sin |
25 years |
|
Ur-Zababa |
400 years |
|
Usiwatar |
6 years |
|
Ishtar-muti |
11 years |
|
Ishme-Shamash |
11 years |
|
Shu-ilishu |
15 years |
|
Simudar |
30 years |
Who is this Shu-ilishu?
‘This king can be no other than the well known Shu-ilishu of Igin and, comparing
the account of the Isin dynasty … we may perhaps assume that the copyist had
a loose, unplaced fragment …’ — and thus Thorkild Jacobsen suggests that
a King of Isin was misplaced by a stupid scribe into the Kish IV Dynasty! (See
page 108 of his ‘Sumerian King List’, footnote 228.)
First, consider the mysterious 400 years. This period begins with the end
of the reign of Puzur-Sin. The 6 years of Ur-Zababa (in the Schell Text) are
a part of the 400 of the other texts. A break in the continuity of the dynasty
is clearly indicated by this unusual figure.
Next, consider the close of the dynasty. One list ends with Nannia — the
other with Simudar. Now to assemble these divergent facts.
Shu-ilishu reigned 10 years after Ishbi-Irra according to the Isin dynastic
list. His dates: 1268-1258. The W.-B Prism 444 states Shu-ilishu’s total reign
as 20 years, but does not count the first 10 in its total. In the Kish list
from Susa his reign is given as 15 — that is, 1273-1258. The following charts
indicate how the remaining kings fit around the reign of Shu-ilishu.
| Names of Kings |
Lengths of Reign |
Dates |
|
Usiwatar |
7 |
1291-1284 |
|
Ishtarmuti |
11 |
1284-1273 |
|
Ishme-Shamash |
11 |
1273-1262 |
|
Nannia |
7 |
1262-1255 |
or
|
Ishtar-muti |
11 |
1284-1273 |
|
Shu-ilishu |
15 |
1273-1258 |
|
Nannia |
3 |
1258-1255 |
and
|
Usiwatar |
6 |
1291-1285 |
|
Simudar |
30 |
1285-1255 |
What is the significance of the dates 1291 and 1255? The year 1291 is the
date of the overthrow of Mari and the return of the old royal family of Kish
to power. And the year 1255 is the date of return of the Chaldeans to power
according to Berossus!
Now place the end of the 400 years in 1255. The beginning of the 400 years
brings us to 1655. The 6 years of Ur-Zababa therefore extend from 1655 to 1649.
This is shortly before the reign of Sargon ‘the Great’ of Akkad. When Sargon
was young he served as cupbearer to Ur-Zababa! (Pallis, ‘Chronology of Shub-Ad
Culture’, p. 360). Thus the 400 years have significance after all!
The reign of Puzur-Sin covers the preceding 25 years: 1680-1655.
But why should Kish IV have ended abruptly in 1649 and Ur-Zababa been slain?
Archaeology answers: Lugal-zaggisi of Erech III overthrew Kish. The inhabitants
were sent into exile. Years later Sargon restored the inhabitants to their estates:
‘Sargon, king of Agade, … king of Kish …. restored Kish, he ordered them
to take again possession of their city’ (Pritchard’s ‘Texts’, p. 267).
The year 1649 is also of unusual significance in the history of India. IN
THE WINTER OF 1650-1649 THE ASSYRIANS WERE DEFEATED ON THE BORDERS OF INDIA,
resulting in collapse of Assyrian confederates in Mesopotamia.
Dynasty of Akshak
At the time Kish was overthrown Akshak was defeated also. The Dynasty of
Akshak appears next.
| Kings of Akshak |
Lengths of Reign |
Dates |
|
Unzi |
30 |
1748-1718 |
|
Undalulu |
12 |
1718-1706 |
|
(or 6) |
(1712-1706) |
|
|
Ur-ur |
6 |
1706-1700 |
|
Puzur-Sahan |
20 |
1700-1680 |
|
Ishuil |
24 |
1680-1656 |
|
Gimil-Sin |
7 |
1656-1649 |
|
(or 24) |
(1656-1632) |
Several of the dates are paralleled with others in contemporary dynasties.
Year 1748 marks the end of the long reign of Mes-Anne-pada of Dynasty I or Ur.
The short reign of 6 years for Uhdalulut second king of Akshak, explains the
extra 6 years of Mes-kiag-Nunna of Ur I. In chart form the two kings’ reigns
appear thus:
|
Mes-kiag-Nunna |
30 |
1748-1718 (Ur I) |
|
Undalulu |
12 |
1718-1706 (Akshak) |
or
|
Mes-kiag-Nunna |
36 |
1748-1712 |
|
Undalulu |
6 |
1712-1706 |
But the relationship does not end here. Under Akshak’s king Puzur-Sahan aging
Queen Ku-Baba of Kish III gained unusual reputation for her ‘pious deeds.’ As
a result her son Puzur-Sin came to royal estate upon the death of Puzur-Sahan
in 1680. (See Pallis’ ‘Shub-Ad Culture’, pp. 359-360.) Notice that in the restoration
of Kish IV the year 1680 is already marked as the commencement of the reign
of Puzur-Sin, the son of Queen Ku-Baba! Here again is harmony among contemporary
dynasties. Though Akshak lost power in 1649 the last king, Gimil-Sin (1656-1649),
is assigned in the Susa List a total reign of 24 years (1656-1632) to the reign
of Sargon of Akkad.
Dates of Queen Ru-Baba
Only one more Dynasty needs to be firmly established — Kish III. Kish III
is famous for a one-time woman wine merchant who became Queen. Her son and grandson
ruled during her late years as the first two Kings of Kish’s Dynasty IV. Since
Dynasty III of Kish is at times listed first and on occasion later than the
Dynasty of Akshak, it must have begun at the same time as Akshak. The dates
of Kish III are therefore 1748-1648. Who the husband or the father of Queen
Ku-Baba may have been is not stated in the lists. That she continued one year
after the death (in 1649) of Ur-Zababa, her grandson, is clear from the statement
of Sargon. He claims that she adopted him as her own son in place of her own
heir now dead (S. Lloyd, ‘Mesopotamia’, page 140).
It becomes clear with this restoration that Dynasties I and II of Kish are
limited to the time between 2254 and 1748, with Kish I ending in the days of
Gilgamesh.
With this account the clouded history of Babylonia to the era of Hammurabi
closes. It is a period of nearly twelve centuries of strife division and wars.

Leave A Comment