RAGNAROK
THE AGE OF FIRE AND GRAVEL.
BY
IGNATIUS DONNELLY
AUTHOR OF “ATLANTIS: THE ANTEDILUVIAN WORLD.”
[1883]
PART III
The Legends
CHAPTER I
THE NATURE OF MYTHS
IN a primitive people the mind of one generation precisely repeats the minds
of all former generations; the construction of the intellectual nature varies
no more, from age to age, than the form of the body or the color of the skin;
the generations feel the same emotions, and think the same thoughts, and use the
same expressions. And this is to be expected, for the brain is as much a part
of the inheritable, material organization as the color of the eyes or the shape
of the nose.
The minds of men move automatically: no man thinks because he intends to think;
he thinks, as he hungers and thirsts, under a great primal necessity; his thoughts
come out from the inner depths of his being as the flower is developed by forces
rising through the roots of the plant.
The female bird says to herself, “The time is propitious, and now, of my own
free will, and under the operation of my individual judgment, I will lay a nestful
of eggs and batch a brood of children.” But it is unconscious that it is moved
by a physical necessity, which has constrained all its ancestors from the beginning
of time,
and which will constrain all its posterity to the end of time; that its will
is nothing more than an expression of age, development, sunlight, food, and “the
skyey influences.” If it were otherwise it would be in the power of a generation
to arrest the life of a race.
All great thoughts are inspirations of God. They are part of the mechanism
by which he advances the race; they are new varieties created out of old genera.
There come bursts of creative force in history, when great thoughts are born,
and then again Brahma, as the Hindoos say, goes to sleep for ages.
But, when the fever of creation comes, the poet, the inventor, or the philosopher
can no more arrest the development of his own thoughts than the female bird, by
her will-power, can stop the growth of the ova within her, or arrest the fever
in the blood which forces her to incubation.
The man who wrote the Shakespeare plays recognized this involuntary operation
of even his own transcendent intellect, when he said:
“Our poesy is a gum which oozes
From whence ’tis nourished.”
It came as the Arabian tree distilled its “medicinal gum”; it was the mere
expression of an internal force, as much beyond his control as the production
of the gum was beyond the control of the tree.
But in primitive races mind repeats mind for thousands of years. If a tale
is told at a million hearth-fires, the probabilities are small, indeed, that any
innovation at one hearth-fire, however ingenious, will work its way into and modify
the narration at all the rest. There is no printing-press to make the thoughts
of one man the thoughts of thousands. While the innovator is modifying the tale,
to his own satisfaction, to his immediate circle of hearers, the narrative is
being repeated in its unchanged form at all the rest. The doctrine of chances
is against innovation. The majority rules.
When, however, a marvelous tale is told to the new generation–to the little
ones sitting around with open eyes and gaping mouths–they naturally ask, “Where
did all this occur?” The narrator must satisfy this curiosity, and so he replies,
“On yonder mountain-top,” or “In yonder cave.”
The story has come down without its geography, and a new geography is given
it.
Again, an ancient word or name may have a signification in the language in
which the story is told different from that which it possessed in the original
dialect, and, in the effort to make the old fact and the new language harmonize,
the story-teller is forced, gradually, to modify the narrative; and, as this lingual
difficulty occurs at every fireside, at every telling, an ingenious explanation
comes at last to be generally accepted, and the ancient myth remains dressed in
a new suit of linguistic clothes.
But, as a rule, simple races repeat; they do not invent.
One hundred years ago the highest faith was placed in written history, while
the utmost contempt was felt for all legends. Whatever had been written down was
regarded as certainly true; whatever had not been written down was necessarily
false.
We are reminded of that intellectual old brute, Dr. Samuel Johnson, trampling
poor Macpherson under foot, like an enraged elephant, for daring to say that he
had collected from the mountaineers of wild Scotland the poems of Ossian, and
that they had been transmitted, from mouth to mouth, through ages. But the great
epic of the son of Fingal will survive, part of the widening heritage of humanity,
while Johnson is remembered only as a coarse-souled, ill-mannered incident in
the development of the great English people.
But as time rolled on it was seen that the greater part of history was simply
recorded legends, while all the rest represented the passions of factions, the
hates of sects, or the servility and venality of historians. Men perceived that
the common belief of antiquity, as expressed in universal tradition, was much
more likely to be true than the written opinions of a few prejudiced individuals.
And then grave and able men,–philosophers, scientists,–were seen with note-books
and pencils, going out into Hindoo villages, into German cottages, into Highland
huts, into Indian tepees, in short, into all lands, taking down with the
utmost care, accuracy, and respect, the fairy-stories, myths, and legends of the
people;–as repeated by old peasant-women, “the knitters in the sun,” or by “gray-haired
warriors, famous for fights.”
And, when they came to put these narratives in due form, and, as it were, in
parallel columns, it became apparent that they threw great floods of light upon
the history of the world, and especially upon the question of the unity of the
race. They proved that all the nations were repeating the same stories, in some
cases in almost identical words, just as their ancestors had heard them, in some
most ancient land, in “the dark background and abysm of time,” when the progenitors
of the German, Gaul, Gael, Greek, Roman, Hindoo, Persian, Egyptian, Arabian, and
the red-people of America, dwelt together under the same roof-tree and used the
same language.
But, above all, these legends prove the absolute fidelity of the memory of
the races.
We are told that the bridge-piles driven by the Romans, two thousand years
ago, in the rivers of Europe, from which the surrounding waters have excluded
the decaying atmosphere, have remained altogether unchanged in their condition.
If this has been the case for two thousand years, why would they not remain unchanged
for ten thousand, for a hundred thousand years? If the ice in which that Siberian
mammoth was incased had preserved it intact for a hundred years, or a thousand
years, why might it not have preserved it for ten thousand, for a hundred thousand
years?
Place a universal legend in the minds of a race, let them repeat it from generation
to generation, and time ceases to be an element in the problem.
Legend has one great foe to its perpetuation–civilization.
Civilization brings with it a contempt for everything which it can not understand;
skepticism becomes the synonym for intelligence; men no longer repeat; they doubt;
they dissect; they sneer; they reject; they invent. If the myth survives this
treatment, the poets take it up and make it their stock in trade: they decorate
it in a masquerade of frippery and finery, feathers and furbelows, like a clown
dressed for a fancy ball; and the poor barbarian legend survives at last, if it
survives at all, like the Conflagration in Ovid or King Arthur in Tennyson–a
hippopotamus smothered in flowers, jewels, and laces.
Hence we find the legends of the primitive American Indians adhering quite
closely to the events of the past, while the myths that survive at all among the
civilized nations of Europe are found in garbled forms, and. only among the peasantry
of remote districts.
In the future more and more attention will be given to the myths of primitive
races; they will be accounted as more reliable, and as reaching farther back in
time than many things which we call history. Thoughtful men will analyze them,
despising nothing; like a chemist who resolves some compound object into its original
elements–the very combination constituting a history of the object.
H. H. Bancroft describes myths as–
“A mass of fragmentary truth and fiction, not open to rationalistic criticism;
a partition wall of allegories, built of dead facts cemented with wild fancies;
it looms ever between the immeasurable and the measurable past.”
But he adds:
“Never was there a time in the history of philosophy when the character, customs,
and beliefs of aboriginal man, and everything appertaining to him, were held in
such high esteem by scholars as at present.”
“It is now a recognized principle of philosophy that no religious belief, however
crude, nor any historical tradition, however absurd, can be held by the majority
of a people for any considerable time as true, without having had in the beginning
some foundation in fact.” [1]
An universal myth points to two conclusions:
First, that it is based on some fact.
Secondly, that it dates back, in all probability, to the time when the ancestors
of the races possessing it had not yet separated.
A myth should be analyzed carefully; the fungi that have attached themselves
to it should be brushed off; the core of fact should be separated from the decorations
and errors of tradition.
But above all, it must be remembered that we can not depend upon either the
geography or the chronology of a myth. As I have shown, there is a universal tendency
to give the old story a new habitat, and hence we have Ararats and Olympuses all
over the world. In the same
[1. “The Native Races of America,” vol. iii, p. 14.]
way the myth is always brought down and attached to more recent events:
“All over Europe-in Germany, France, Spain, Switzerland, England, Scotland,
Ireland–the exploits of the oldest mythological heroes, figuring in the Sagas,
Eddas, and Nibelungen Lied, have been ascribed, in the folk-lore and ballads of
the people, to Barbarossa, Charlemagne, Boabdil, Charles V, William Tell, Arthur,
Robin Hood, Wallace, and St. Patrick.” [1]
In the next place, we must remember how impossible it is for the mind to invent
an entirely new fact.
What dramatist or novelist has ever yet made a plot which did not consist of
events that had already transpired somewhere on earth? He might intensify events,
concentrate and combine them, or amplify them; but that is all. Men in all ages
have suffered from jealousy,–like Othello; have committed murders,–like Macbeth;
have yielded to the sway of morbid minds,–like Hamlet; have stolen, lied, and
debauched,–like Falstaff;–there are Oliver Twists, Bill Sykeses, and Nancies;
Micawbers, Pickwicks, and Pecksniffs in every great city.
There is nothing in the mind of man that has not preexisted in nature. Can
we imagine a person, who never saw or heard of an elephant, drawing a picture
of such a two-tailed creature? It was thought at one time that man had made the
flying-dragon out of his own imagination; but we now know that the image of the
pterodactyl had simply descended from generation to generation. Sindbad’s
great bird, the roc, was considered a flight of the Oriental fancy, until
science revealed the bones of the dinornis. All the winged beasts breathing
fire are simply a recollection of the comet.
In fact, even with the patterns of nature before it, the
[1. Bancroft, “Native Races,” note, vol. iii, p. 17.]
human mind has not greatly exaggerated them: it has never drawn a bird larger
than the dinornis or a beast greater than the mammoth.
It is utterly impossible that the races of the whole world, of all the continents
and islands, could have preserved traditions from the most remote ages, of a comet
having struck the earth, of the great heat, the conflagration, the cave-life,
the age of darkness, and the return of the sun, and yet these things have had
no basis of fact. It was not possible for the primitive mind to have imagined
these things if they had never occurred.

Leave A Comment